Ideas

Career Guidance Works. Now, It’s Within Reach for Everyone.

By Kyle Nelson & Aras Jizan

Published on

11 min read

Most people make big career decisions alone. A new generation of AI tools could change that, if we build them with and for the people who need them most.

Meet Dana: She’s spent six years as a cashier at a hardware chain, and her shifts have been cut twice since the company moved to using self-checkout registers. She has heard that medical assistants are in demand, and her community college offers a nine-month certificate. But she has questions no one around her seems to be able to answer. Will local employers actually hire those graduates? Can she afford to go part-time while she trains? Would a bigger paycheck cost her family its childcare subsidy?Dana is a real woman from Virginia, though we’ve changed her name to protect her identity. And there are millions of Americans just like her, who are weighing similar questions in a job market that is getting harder to read. The typical unemployed American has been looking for work for more than 11 weeks (opens in a new tab), and only 28 percent of workers (opens in a new tab) say this is a good time to find a quality job, down from 70 percent in 2022. AI adds another layer of uncertainty: Experts expect it to create, change, and eliminate jobs – maybe even entire career paths – and no one can say what the market will look like in five years.

People like Dana can’t wait for clarity; they have to decide now. And today’s decisions will have long-term effects on their futures. Landing a first full-time job with room to advance is associated with a 24 percent increase in lifetime income (opens in a new tab); job or skills training, with 19 percent. Good guidance helps people get these decisions right.Yet most people face these decisions alone. Ask someone how they are navigating a career change and the answer may include some combination of a generic aptitude test, a job board, a free chatbot to polish a resume, or advice from friends and family. Some communities have a job center with a list of training programs and a stack of forms. Few people have a professional counselor. Even where one is available, they’re often stretched thin. Community college advisors, for example, carry a median of 441 students each (opens in a new tab). Quality career guidance is scarcest for the people who need it most.

AI should be able to help, but so far it mostly works for the other side of the table. Nearly all Fortune 500 companies screen applications through automated systems, and most hiring managers now use AI to sort resumes (opens in a new tab). Job seekers respond with chatbots that churn out applications. One machine writes a generic resume, another rejects it, and the person in the middle never reaches a human. This trend is increasingly common and increasingly frustrating (opens in a new tab). But what if AI were on the worker’s side? Not a chatbot that writes a stale cover letter for another chatbot to discard, but something closer to an experienced career counselor: A tool that learns a person’s history, strengths, constraints, and goals, and stays with them as they make the next decision and act on it.

That kind of guidance has always existed. It just hasn’t been equally accessible. If someone can afford a private coach or has a parent in the right profession, they get a leg up. Everyone else gets only a job board. The limit was never whether personalized guidance works. It is how many counselors there are and how much one can pay.

Until now.

How NavTech Could Unlock Career Guidance For All

We already know intensive career coaching works: Sector-focused training programs with dedicated coaches (opens in a new tab) have produced lasting earnings gains of 11 to 40 percent in randomized trials. The obstacle to making that kind of support available to everyone was cost. Recent advances in AI (opens in a new tab) have changed that, making it possible to build people-centered tools that deliver personalized support at scale. We call this category Navigation Technology, or NavTech.

A Google search can tell Dana that healthcare is a growing field. A NavTech tool can tell her what graduates of her college’s medical assistant program actually earn, which nearby employers are hiring, and whether the class schedule works with her childcare. It can remember her goals so she doesn’t start over at every fork in the road, check in if she starts to fall behind, and bring in a human coach when she needs one. And it frees those coaches from busywork so they can do what they do best: Connect, motivate, and advocate.

That’s what career navigation should look like for everyone – personalized support from your first career question to your first paycheck. To make that vision a reality, we need four things working together:

  1. A front door anyone can walk through. A generalist guide that helps people explore their options and set goals, whether they’re finishing high school or starting over after a layoff. It remembers who they are and carries their context across tools and institutions, so no one has to start from scratch.
  2. Depth where the jobs are. A front door helps people access information and choose a direction, but getting hired takes more than that. Sector-specific tools in fields like healthcare and skilled trades, tied to real employer relationships, can unlock public funds to cover training costs and help people land good jobs and succeed in them. They also have a natural customer in employers and public-sector programs with a direct stake in filling key jobs in every local market.
  3. Support for the whole person. Careers often stall for reasons that have nothing to do with what happens at work: An incremental raise that would cost someone their childcare subsidy, a broken-down car, bills that pile up during training. Good navigation helps people spot these problems early and connects them with help, from benefits counseling to emergency aid to training funds they didn’t know they qualified for. Instead of handing someone a phone number and leaving them to explain their situation all over again, it passes along what it already knows, with their permission.
  4. Trust in both directions. People need to trust a tool enough to share what’s really going on, and to trust what it tells them in return. The first depends on privacy, safety and real control over their own data. The second depends on guidance that is accurate, fair and grounded in reality. Both are earned through careful evaluation and close partnership with the communities and institutions people already rely on, and the field has work to do on both fronts.

The technology to make this real is within reach, but today’s tools still fall short. General-purpose AI assistants are a real step forward. If Dana asks one about becoming a medical assistant, she’ll get a far better answer than a Google search gives her. But it won’t know what graduates of different programs at her community college actually earn, and it can be confidently wrong about key details and local resources. Because it isn’t connected to her college, local employers, or the agencies that could help, it won’t notice if she stops showing up to class, and its support will end when the chat does. Connecting all the dots is still completely up to her.

The market won’t fill these gaps on its own. The people who need these tools most usually can’t pay for them, so institutions such as community colleges, workforce boards, and training programs pay on their behalf. Those already stretched buyers are rightly skeptical about whether the tools work, are safe to use, and will see any uptake. The outcomes that matter most, from higher earnings to whether people feel more in control of their careers, can take years to show up, and the field hasn’t agreed on the early signals that predict them. So buyers fall back on brand, incumbency, and price, while quality goes unrewarded.

Faced with that, builders feel a natural pull toward wealthier customers. The same product is worth more, and is far easier to sell, to a laid-off software engineer than to someone like Dana. We’ve watched several venture-backed companies set out to serve workers like her, then pivot to more affluent customers. That leaves an opportunity for entrepreneurs focused on impact and for patient, mission-aligned capital willing to go first and prove the market for other investors to come along. It’s why we launched NextLadder Ventures.

NextLadder’s Approach

Over the next year, we aim to make investments in career navigation tools that put more than $1 billion in additional Dollars in Pockets (opens in a new tab) of low-income Americans by connecting them to better training, quality jobs, and higher lifetime earnings. At the same time, we’re making sure the tools we invest in grow the user’s sense of control over their career journey and dignity in the process. To do this, we’re working on both sides of the problem: Backing the tools people need, and building a market that rewards the ones that work.

As a first step, we’re making a big bet on the front door: A $10 million commitment (opens in a new tab) to CareerVillage (opens in a new tab). CareerVillage has been providing tools that give accessible, vetted career guidance to learners and workers for over a decade. We believe their latest Coach (opens in a new tab) product is the strongest candidate to be the front door the field needs. Why?

  • It covers the whole journey. Coach offers tested guidance across more than 30 navigation tasks, from exploring careers and choosing training to staying enrolled and landing a job. It remembers a person’s context from one session, and one institution, to the next.
  • It’s free to the people who use it. Coach is primarily designed to reach people through employers and the community colleges, workforce boards, and training programs that already serve them. These institutions pay for the tool, so learners and job seekers never have to. Individuals outside of formal institutional contexts are also able to access Coach at no cost.
  • It’s built with best-in-class quality control systems. Coach is tested against 180+ evaluations and developed with certified career coaches who score its guidance for accuracy, bias, contextual relevance, and more. CareerVillage curates the data Coach draws on, from sources like O*NET, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, and College Scorecard so that guidance is grounded in factual evidence and labor market reality.
  • It is easy to access and use. Coach is designed to be reached wherever a person is or how they work and learn, whether over web, text, and WhatsApp. Where it is built into a skills program, it is seamlessly embedded into the learning systems already in place. An independent worker can also use the tool directly without having to be enrolled in a formal program.
  • It makes the whole field better. CareerVillage has extraordinary reach already — answering career questions for more than 13 million people — making it a clear industry leader. And because they’re working on AI benchmarks and open-source tools, they’re helping other builders raise the bar, too.

Early results are promising. In a pilot with Per Scholas, a training program already known for real earnings gains, learners using Coach were 33 percent more likely to finish and earn their certificate than peers without it. Completion is exactly the kind of early signal the field needs to show what works long before earnings data arrives.

Coach is our first big bet, but not our only one. To reward what works, buyers need trustworthy ways to tell good tools from bad: Rigorous impact evaluations, shared benchmarks and real-world pilots inside the institutions that serve people like Dana. We’re starting by funding Vals AI (opens in a new tab) to test how well products and models handle career navigation tasks. And we’re partnering with several other philanthropies to launch the Career Navigation Collaborative, which will deploy and evaluate several tools side by side and learn what institutions need to see before they buy.

We’re also looking to back the rest of the vision: Tools that bring depth where the jobs are, tied closely to sector-specific workforce programs in growing fields like healthcare and skilled trades, and tools that support the whole person, working at the seams between career navigation and benefits, housing, care and health.

Join Us

Today, Dana’s experience of AI in her career is limited to generic search result summaries and employer screening tools. We believe it can do much more: Help her choose the right program, see her through it, and help her land a job that supports her family and unlocks opportunity for the next generation.

We can’t build that future alone. We especially want to hear from:

  • Builders working on memory that follows a person across tools, referrals that confirm someone actually got help, or local labor market data good enough to tell someone which jobs are within reach of home.
  • Colleges, workforce boards, training programs, and employers ready to try new tools with the people they serve and hire.
  • Funders and investors who want to back this work alongside us.
  • AI companies motivated to make their general-purpose assistants work better for the people who need them most.

Get in touch at info@nextladder.com and expect some more specific open calls from us in the coming months. Let’s build better lives, today.

Build

with

Us

Whether you have a question, would like to learn more about NextLadder, or are interested in becoming an investor, we’re here to help.

Get Started